Best Car Insurance for Families with Young Drivers

If your teenager just got their licence, how should you go about insuring them? Canstar looks at the best car insurance for families with young drivers.

Young drivers are the riskiest drivers on the road. Statistically speaking at least. And that risk is reflected in car insurance for young drivers, which typically comes at a premium. So if you’ve got a young driver in the family, should you grab them their own policy, or add them to yours? Canstar looks at your options, as well as the best car insurance for families with young drivers.

Car insurance for young drivers: what are your options?

You have a few options when it comes to insuring a young driver. And the best option can be difficult to get your head around. The three main options available to you are:

  • Add your child to your car insurance policy
  • Get them their own car insurance policy
  • Not to include them on your insurance because your insurance provides appropriate cover

Add your child to your car insurance policy

This is likely the best option if your child is particularly young, new to the roads, and/or not on a full licence. With this option, you include your child as a driver of your vehicle/another vehicle (that is in your name). Your premiums will likely go up to reflect the added risk of having a young driver on the policy, but you can sleep easy knowing that they’re covered when out driving your car.

As long as the vehicles are registered in your name, you can cover multiple vehicles under your policy. Including one for your child. So you don’t have to share cars if you don’t want to. But do note, that if your child will be driving their own vehicle (registered in your name) or will be using the vehicle the most, you will need to list them as the main driver of that vehicle.

This will likely impact your premiums more than if they simply borrowed your car every now and then.

However, even if you are the registered owner of a vehicle, and the insurance is in your name, the main person driving the vehicle must be listed as the main driver on the policy. Doing otherwise (like listing yourself as the main driver to lower premiums) is illegal.

Get them their own car insurance policy

Firstly, you can’t insure what you don’t own. So if your child is the registered owner of a vehicle, they will need their own policy. If your child is a young driver (under 25) but is independent and working, then they should be able to afford their own policy. It’ll probably cost more than your insurance does, but it shouldn’t be too astronomical, as long as they’ve got a clean driving history.

You can find the best car insurance for young drivers here, as well as some tips to save on car insurance.

If your child will simply be using your car or using a car registered in your name, then you can add them to your insurance policy, as mentioned above.

Not to include them on your insurance

Car insurance policies provide cover for the occasional driver, so long as they meet the terms of your policy. It’s for this reason you can safely lend your car to a mate for the day, and not have to worry about insurance.

Do be careful, though. The driver must meet the same standards as you. Your insurer agreed to your policy based on the idea that you were driving your car, so if you’re on a full licence and well into your 30s, and you lend it to a 23-year-old restricted driver, it may not be covered.

Always check what your policy says (or with your insurer). Don’t just assume someone is or isn’t covered.

But, if your child meets the terms of the insurance (as confirmed by your insurer) and isn’t going to use your car often, you could be okay to not include them on the policy at all. On the rare occasion they do drive, they’ll still be covered.

For example, some insurance plans will automatically include cover for learner drivers. This is designed to allow parents to teach their children to drive without worry. Well, insurance worry, at least. Teaching a teenager to drive is scary enough!

However, not all policies include this automatically. You may have to add learner driver cover. So always check before letting your child behind the wheel.

While this type of cover most likely won’t impact your premiums, it will come with a host of added excesses. In addition to the standard excess, you may have to pay:

  • Learner driver excess: added excess for a claim made as the result of a learner driver
  • Young driver excess: added excess if they’re under 25
  • Inexperienced driver excess: usually applies to learner drivers over the age of 25
  • Undeclared driver excess: if you didn’t list a learner driver on your policy, your premiums were likely unaffected. But you may have to pay extra excess as a result

All of the above is on top of the standard excess, so it can quickly add up. That’s why it can pay to add your child to your policy. It may just be cheaper.

→Related article: Car Insurance for Learner Drivers

Best Car Insurance for Families with young drivers

If you do intend to add your child to your car insurance policy, you’ll want an insurer that won’t punish you for it. While higher premiums are likely, with the right insurer, you can still get great value. This is where Canstar comes in.

Each year, we release our car insurance awards, covering winners for Insurer of the Year, Outstanding Value, and Most Satisfied Customers. As part of our award results, you can view our Outstanding Value Star Ratings for different age groups, to help you find the best car insurance for you and your family. You can view our 5-Star winners for NZ Family with Young Driver below, or click here to view our car insurance Star Ratings, in full.

5-Star Car Insurance Winners: NZ Family with Young Driver

Star Rating



Further Information

Everyday Plus
FMG Comprehensive


Compare Car Insurance

author andrew broadley

About the author of this page

This report was written by Canstar Content Producer, Andrew Broadley. Andrew is an experienced writer with a wide range of industry experience. Starting out, he cut his teeth working as a writer for print and online magazines, and he has worked in both journalism and editorial roles. His content has covered lifestyle and culture, marketing and, more recently, finance for Canstar.

Enjoy reading this article?

You can like us on Facebook and get social, or sign up to receive more news like this straight to your inbox.

By subscribing you agree to the Canstar Privacy Policy

Share this article